Why did Cassandra Austen destroy Jane’s letters?

Jane Austen, renowned for her sharp insights into 19th-century English culture, was an avid letter writer during her lifetime. Yet, merely around 160 of her letters remain today. This scarcity is mostly attributed to her older sister, Cassandra Austen, who burned a large number of their letters following Jane’s passing. This decision has captivated both scholars and enthusiasts, sparking debates about Cassandra’s reasons and the knowledge that may have vanished with those letters.

The Strong Connection Between Siblings

Cassandra Austen, born in 1773, was older than Jane by two years. The sisters had a remarkably close bond, frequently characterized by deep mutual love and comprehension. As the only daughters in a family of eight children, they spent a significant portion of their lives side by side, assisting one another in both personal and career-related pursuits. The letters that remain showcase their close relationship, brimming with personal stories, critiques of literature, and musings on everyday experiences.

Cassandra’s Choice to Burn the Letters

In the years after Jane passed away in 1817, Cassandra assumed the responsibility of examining their vast collection of letters. She meticulously burned many of them and altered others, cutting out parts she considered sensitive. This intentional editing has sparked discussion among historians. While some see it as an act of literary destruction, denying future generations important glimpses into Jane’s private life and creative journey, others see it as a protective measure meant to guard her sister’s privacy and protect family members from possible negative depictions.

In the years following Jane’s death in 1817, Cassandra took it upon herself to review their extensive correspondence. She systematically burned a large number of letters and edited others, removing sections she deemed sensitive. This deliberate curation has been a subject of debate among historians. Some view it as an act of literary vandalism, depriving posterity of valuable insights into Jane’s personal life and creative process. Others interpret it as a protective gesture, aimed at preserving her sister’s privacy and shielding family members from potentially unflattering portrayals.

Possible Motivations Behind the Destruction

1. Salvaguardar la Reputación de Jane: Durante el siglo XIX, las normas sociales valorizaban mucho la privacidad personal y la corrección. Las cartas de Jane, conocidas por su franqueza y a veces agudo ingenio, podían haber tenido comentarios que se malinterpretaran o consideraran inadecuados. Al destruirlas, Cassandra pudo haber querido mantener la imagen de su hermana como una mujer respetable y amable.
2. Mantener la Privacidad Familiar: La familia Austen, como cualquier otra, tenía sus asuntos personales y dinámicas internas. Las cartas probablemente incluían menciones a problemas familiares, opiniones sobre conocidos y otros detalles íntimos. Cassandra pudo haber querido evitar cualquier posible vergüenza o malentendidos que pudieran surgir de un escrutinio público.
3. Duelo Personal y Catarsis: La pérdida de Jane fue un golpe profundo para Cassandra. Llevar a cabo la destrucción de las cartas pudo haber sido una forma de procesar su dolor, permitiéndole dejar atrás el pasado y encontrar cierre.

Repercusiones en el Estudio Literario

La eliminación de estas cartas ha dejado, sin duda, vacíos en el registro histórico. Biógrafos y estudiosos de la literatura a menudo han lamentado esta pérdida, especulando sobre las posibles revelaciones sobre el desarrollo de los personajes de Jane Austen, sus fuentes de inspiración y sus relaciones personales que se desvanecieron para siempre. Las cartas que aún existen brindan vislumbres invaluables de su mundo, pero la amplitud completa de sus pensamientos y experiencias sigue siendo desconocida.

The destruction of these letters has undeniably left gaps in the historical record. Biographers and literary scholars have often lamented the loss, speculating on the potential insights into Jane Austen’s character development, narrative inspirations, and personal relationships that were irrevocably erased. The surviving letters offer invaluable glimpses into her world, but the full breadth of her thoughts and experiences remains obscured.

Reevaluating Cassandra’s Legacy

In recent years, there has been a shift towards a more empathetic understanding of Cassandra’s actions. Rather than viewing her solely as the executor of a significant literary loss, some scholars and writers have portrayed her as a devoted sister who played a crucial role in Jane’s life and legacy. For instance, contemporary novelist Gill Hornby explored Cassandra’s perspective in her work, shedding light on the complexities of her character and the possible reasons behind her decisions.